by overd0se.KayKay Sun Jan 31, 2010 10:47 amOk. I was in a tournament in my city. Then I saw a match. Player 1 used Dandylion. Then he played Creature Swap. Dandylion was on the oppenents side of the field. Then player 1 used fissure. Who gets the tokens?? The Judge said that the tokens summon at player 2's field. I meant he is like Sangan.
3 posters
Dandylion effect
overd0se.KayKay
Posts : 200
Speed Credits : 2611
Location : Germany
Reputation : 0
The Detonator- Posts : 1147
Speed Credits : 850
Reputation : 29
Personally i believe the judge is incorrect.
(Honestly where do they get these people from?)
You have compared Dandylion to Sangan and this is a good comparison to make because they both work in exactly the same way.
Both effects are written in the following way: "when this card... an effect occurs". They don't differ in their wording and niether do the way their effects activate and resolve.
Because Dandylion is sent to Player 1's Graveyard, Player 1 gets the effect, not Player 2. The same applies with Sangan.
--The Detonator--
(Honestly where do they get these people from?)
You have compared Dandylion to Sangan and this is a good comparison to make because they both work in exactly the same way.
Both effects are written in the following way: "when this card... an effect occurs". They don't differ in their wording and niether do the way their effects activate and resolve.
Because Dandylion is sent to Player 1's Graveyard, Player 1 gets the effect, not Player 2. The same applies with Sangan.
--The Detonator--
WilBer
Posts : 508
Speed Credits : 1616
Location : alien
Reputation : 0
yay i completely sure its summoned on the owner field -.-
how the hell the judge can do wrong i think he should has pass the judge test or sumthing ._.
how the hell the judge can do wrong i think he should has pass the judge test or sumthing ._.
|
|
|